Oil and Water - Cardinal Sin

How did we fool ourselves 
to think this could last 
not to mention the fact 
we gave it more than one chance 
I will kill anyone who says opposites attract 
I know first hand that is not always correct won't you please spend the night 
if only for tonight 
what the hell am I thinking 
when I miss saying your name 
I doubt you feel the same 
we were like water and oil 
like night and day it was clear from afar 
you may be beautiful and why I am drunk at the bar 
a lot of things we said were not eye to eye 
you have faith in religion 
and I have turned away from mine 
still I have to say 
I would do it again